Why Look Beyond College Rankings?

College Rankings

Why Look Beyond College Rankings?

Published October 10, 2017

College Rankings

College Rankings - NO
What makes 50 or fewer colleges so much more attractive than the remaining 1500? Can you say “US News Best College Rankings?”

 

For those who want the short version, the problem with rankings is deciding what to rank. In the case of US News, popularity is a major factor in their rankings; though in their language it’s called “reputation” and it accounts for over 20% of the rankings.

 

For the purposes of the rankings, “reputation” is measured by a survey of college officials who US News believes are objective about the ranking process. In fact, US News explicitly states that “reputation” shouldn’t be based on measurable criteria. Hmmm, so the criteria with the biggest influence on ranking is just based on opinion?

 

 

What Do College Rankings Actually Mean?

If you believe that rankings are an indicator of popularity, then more students with better qualifications will be applying to these schools. Combining this with the theory of supply and demand, as more students apply, acceptance rates decline and college prices increase.

 

The question is “Does a higher-ranked school deliver a better education that justifies a higher price?”

 

Some would argue that a higher-priced college does deliver more value and a better return on your investment. But that’s hard to conclude because it’s difficult to account for the different qualifications of students that by the nature of the higher rankings they attract. And colleges aren’t forth coming in supplying information on salaries and graduate school acceptance rates.

 

In a way, the answer to the question is irrelevant as far as paying for colleges goes. The fact is that the rankings exist and if you want to attend a higher-ranked school, you can expect to pay more.

 

Among the schools ranked in the top 30, 21 gave 60% or less of freshman institutional grants, 12 schools provided 50% or less. There were only two schools where 80% or more of freshman received institutional grants. Of the 18 schools ranked between 30 and 50, half awarded less than 60% of freshman institutional aid. Two, colleges ranked 40 and 45, provide more than 80% of freshman with institutional aid.1

 

Of the next 50 schools (52 because of ties), 90% or more of freshman at 40 of the colleges, received institutional aid. Only three, one of them a public college, had less than 60% of freshman with institutional aid.1

 

Now some would argue that the higher cost colleges deliver more value, a better return on your investment. That’s hard to say and not only because you need to account for the different qualifications of the students. The fact is that colleges haven’t been exactly forthcoming in supplying information on salaries and acceptance rates into graduate school.

 

The College Scorecard data includes median earning after 10 years information. This data has all kinds of limitations including not being adjusted for majors. However, until colleges decide to provide more useful information, this is what we have available.

 

Bottom line: Don’t judge the value of a college based on its ranking. If you can’t prove a higher-ranked college is worth the cost, why not consider a lower-ranked school that gives you a better deal? 

 

1Based on IPEDS and Common Data Set data in the Road2College College Data Spreadsheet.

 

 

CONNECT WITH OTHER PARENTS TRYING TO FIGURE OUT

HOW TO PAY FOR COLLEGE 

 

JOIN ONE OR ALL OF OUR FACEBOOK GROUPS:

PAYING FOR COLLEGE 101

HOW TO FIND MERIT SCHOLARSHIPS

 

 

In this article:

Upcoming Events

Similar Articles for You

Stay on Track With This College Application Checklist

ACT Prep

Stay on Track With This College Application Checklist

Students and families need to stay on track to find the right college at the right price, so we’re providing...

Why Starting College in the Spring or Summer Might Be Your Best College Move Yet

Apply

Why Starting College in the Spring or Summer Might Be Your Best College Move Yet

As colleges wrap up their acceptances and denials for the next fall, many students are receiving deferrals that grant them...

4 Game-Changing Ways That One Family Mastered the College Application Journey

Advice

4 Game-Changing Ways That One Family Mastered the College Application Journey

Kristin Bachtell, a parent in our Paying for College 101 Facebook Group, calls herself a planner — but not just...

Become a Member

At Road2College you’ll find everything you need to make the admissions and paying for college process less stressful and more transparent.

TOOLS

Explore R2C Insights™ — your source for finding affordable colleges and merit scholarships.

Coaching

Get coaching on admissions and college financing.

Community

Join Road2College where parents and experts work together to inform and inspire college-bound families.