Are Private Student Loans the Better, Cheaper Option?

sticky note next to magnifying glass that says "Explore Your Options"

Are Private Student Loans the Better, Cheaper Option?

Published June 21, 2019 | Last Updated February 28th, 2024 at 04:37 pm

sticky note next to magnifying glass that says "Explore Your Options"

Not too long ago, the student loan world was a lot like the Wild West.

Back then, it was a common belief that private student loans were the “bad guys,” and federal loans like the Parent PLUS loan, were the “good guys.”

That way of thinking has changed and private student loans are now, in many cases, becoming the right choice.

They may have lower rates, depending on your own credit score and history, than Parent PLUS loans.

They also can be a better option for short-term lending because many don’t have origination fees.

Here’s what you need to know about deciding between federal and private student loans:

What Is an Origination Fee?

An origination fee is a fee for borrowing money that is charged the moment you borrow the loan; something like a “service charge.”

It’s only charged once, then interest accrues in addition to the fee. You need to add the origination fee to the cost of the loan.

For instance, federal student loans charge about one percent of the loan amount for student loans issued directly to students. PLUS loans to graduate students or parents have origination fees of over four percent.

Private student loans are issued by private lenders and most don’t charge these fees.

Parent PLUS loans are rarely recommended if you can pay off the loan within three to five years partly because of origination fees.

How Loan Approval Works

Although it may seem counter-productive for parents, one of the benefits to private student loans is that income is a factor in approval.

Parent PLUS loans may approve families for $100,000 in student loans over the course of four years based on cost of attendance, no matter whether the family can afford the payments or not.

Private lenders consider the ability of the family to afford to repay the loans.

The result is being limited as to how much you can borrow and families possibly reconsidering school choices because of this. It also prevents families from taking on an excessive financial burden, which in the long run, is beneficial for you.

Benefits You’ll Lose When Borrowing a Private Student Loan

There are some benefits you can lose with private student loan borrowing.

Private lenders do sometimes offer forbearance or deferment, but generally the total period of time allowed is two years or less. If you know you’ll borrow the loan for a short period of time, it’s not an issue.

It’s generally not a good idea for students to borrow via a private student loan instead of subsidized or unsubsidized federal loans because the interest rate generally won’t be much lower.

Also, the student will have lost benefits such as income-driven repayment and interest paid by the government while in college on subsidized student loans.

PLUS loans for graduate students are similar to Parent PLUS loans and may be more expensive than borrowing privately.

If borrowing the loan for more than a few years, however, students should be careful to not lose benefits such as income-driven repayment options.

Special Perks of Private Student Loans

In recent years, private student loans have stepped up to actually help students find work after graduation.

College Ave offers things like happy hours, career events, and resources to help find internships.

Before you pick a private lender, call and ask about special perks for your student.

Responsibilities of a Loan Cosigner

If you decide to cosign a private student loan for your student, keep in mind that you are taking on responsibility for these loans. Credit reporting for missed payments will appear on your credit report, as well.

Even when your student needs a break from repayment, lenders will often consider your income, as well.

Thus, make sure you can both repay the loan if you needed to and that you have a thorough talk with your student about repayment responsibilities AND student debt.

You won’t regret either decision.

Quick tips for when to consider private student loans:

  • You know you can pay off the loans in three to five years
  • You still borrow unsubsidized or subsidized federal student loans first
  • The interest is lower than the fixed rate for a Parent PLUS loans
  • You’re okay with repaying a private student loan for your student if they can’t afford the payment

Do you have many student loan offers but don’t know how to choose the best one? Are you struggling to balance monthly payments and loan term? Don’t worry–we have the perfect tool for you!

To help parents and students make informed decisions about student loan costs, we developed the Road2College Student Loan Comparison Spreadsheet, which you can download for free.



In this article:

Upcoming Events

Similar Articles for You

Federal Student Loan Interest Rates 2024 – 2025

Federal Loans

Federal Student Loan Interest Rates 2024 – 2025

The interest rates for federal student loans for the academic year 2024-25 have seen a significant increase of over one...

Dear Roadie, My Son Insists on Borrowing $200K For a School We Can’t Afford. Did I Fail Him as a Parent?


Dear Roadie, My Son Insists on Borrowing $200K For a School We Can’t Afford. Did I Fail Him as a Parent?

Dear Roadie, My child committed to a school we cannot afford. He’ll be in debt for potentially $200,000. We fought...

Complete Guide to Paying for College: Strategies & Tips


Complete Guide to Paying for College: Strategies & Tips

Many families use student loans as the primary way to pay for college. Fortunately, students have various funding options that...

Become a Member

At Road2College you’ll find everything you need to make the admissions and paying for college process less stressful and more transparent.


Explore R2C Insights™ — your source for finding affordable colleges and merit scholarships.


Get coaching on admissions and college financing.


Join Road2College where parents and experts work together to inform and inspire college-bound families.