Which Hurts Your Chances More: Low Grades or Low Test Scores?

which hurts your chances more

Which Hurts Your Chances More: Low Grades or Low Test Scores?

Published August 1, 2019 | Last Updated June 23rd, 2024 at 08:26 pm

which hurts your chances more

Who is in the tougher situation when it comes to getting into college: the student whose high school GPA is lower than ideal or the student whose SAT and/or ACT scores are lower than ideal?

It’s clear that having mediocre or low college admission test scores gives students a better shot both at more colleges and at higher-quality colleges than having mediocre or low high school grades.

Not everyone is a strong test taker.

Some students suffer from severe anxiety when the prospect of taking a standardized test comes up.

But their grades do not reflect that.

While students’ test scores are still important to most top-ranked colleges, there are some colleges—including some excellent colleges—that do not put so much weight, or indeed any weight at all, on college admission test scores.

If you read admission testing policies on a growing number of college websites, you will see that colleges have sometimes done their own research on their own students in order to determine whether SAT or ACT scores have any better predictive value than high school grades—or indeed any predictive value at all—for how students will do in college, including whether they will stay and graduate.

Their research typically shows that admission test scores do not add enough predictive value to require that students take the tests and, thus, to risk shutting out students who do not have easy access to the tests—often lower-income students in urban settings.

Test-Optional Colleges

Some schools choose not to place such a heavy emphasis on test scores and ask that students show evidence of their academic abilities in other ways,

Examples of this could be through essays or a portfolio of their work.

Here are a few of the highly respected “test-optional” colleges that do not require SAT or ACT scores for admission, although students may submit the scores (and many do) if they feel the scores will help their application:

  • American University
  • Bard College
  • Bates College
  • Bennington College
  • Bowdoin College
  • Brandeis University
  • Bryn Mawr College
  • Fairfield University
  • George Washington University
  • Mount Holyoke College
  • New Jersey Institute of Technology
  • Pitzer College
  • Sarah Lawrence College
  • Smith College
  • Wake Forest University
  • Wesleyan University.
  • Wofford College
  • Hampshire College—everyone’s idea of a great school— was one of the first schools to go the test-optional route.

They have taken the most extreme position of any school that we have encountered so far by saying that Hampshire does not consider admission test scores “in any way” either for admission or for financial aid awards.

There are also “test-flexible” colleges.

These are colleges that give students a choice of which admission and/or achievement test scores to submit during the application process.

Some of these policies are more flexible than others, such as that of the University of Rochester which became test-flexible in 2011.

Test-Flexible Colleges

Here are a few highly respected test-flexible colleges:

  • Colorado College
  • Middlebury College
  • New York University
  • University of Rochester

Are there any “high-school-grades-optional” or “high-school-grades-flexible” colleges?

Almost all colleges look at high school grades. However, when a student applies to Bennington College, they can chose the traditional route of filling out the Common App or The Dimensional Application which allows them to submit samples of their work and other items rather than grades.

If there is a reason that high school grades are lower than the student is capable of earning—such as a difficult family situation or a personal health problem—that reason should be explained in a required application essay (when the topic is appropriate) or in an optional supplementary essay.

Whatever the case, it is really very difficult to explain away mediocre or low high school grades.

When a student has mediocre or low high school grades, it is ideal if that student happens to have high SAT or ACT scores.

Then, the college can imagine that the student is bright, but perhaps had some reason for not performing as expected in high school classes.

No such reason would be a great excuse, but some colleges will make an exception for such a student.

However, statistically, students who have mediocre or low high school grades do not have high SAT or ACT scores.

So, start telling middle school students to get ready and remind ninth graders now that there is no easy route to a great college without great high school grades.


Use R2C Insights to help find merit aid and schools that fit the criteria most important to your student. You’ll not only save precious time, but your student will avoid the heartache of applying to schools they aren’t likely to get into or can’t afford to attend.  

👉 Looking for expert help on the road to college? See our Preferred Partner List!

Other Articles You Might Like:

Holistic Admissions: Your Child Is More than Their Grades and Test Scores

Parents Share the Worst Parts of the College Admissions Process

Achieving a Good Score on the SAT: How the Test Works and Tips for Success





In this article:

Upcoming Events

Similar Articles for You

Achieving a Good Score on the SAT: How the Test Works and Tips for Success


Achieving a Good Score on the SAT: How the Test Works and Tips for Success

The SAT, or Scholastic Aptitude Test, is a standardized test administered by the College Board. U.S. colleges widely use it...

How to Write a College Essay That Works


How to Write a College Essay That Works

Millions of high school students apply for college each year, and many have to write at least one college application...

Dear Roadie: Should I Tell My Daughter Not to Bother Applying to Unaffordable Dream Schools?


Dear Roadie: Should I Tell My Daughter Not to Bother Applying to Unaffordable Dream Schools?

Dear Roadie, We just returned from visiting a few colleges and I’m feeling deflated.  My daughter is a high-stat student...

Tools & Services Recommended for You

There may come a time when you realize you can’t do it all alone. Use any of the many tools in our toolbox to assist you on the road to college.

Become a Member

At Road2College you’ll find everything you need to make the admissions and paying for college process less stressful and more transparent.


Explore R2C Insights™ — your source for finding affordable colleges and merit scholarships.


Get coaching on admissions and college financing.


Join Road2College where parents and experts work together to inform and inspire college-bound families.