How Ethical Is Your College Counselor?

college admissions scandal

How Ethical Is Your College Counselor?

Published March 21, 2019

college admissions scandal

The recent scandals surrounding college admissions have been VERY unfortunate.

I’m sure everybody likes hearing about a good scandal now and then, and there are times that I suppose I am guilty of that as well.

However, while the recent events got my attention, I took no pleasure in hearing the details.

As a college admissions professional, I received a lot of phone calls, texts, and had to field a lot of questions from both enraged and disheartened parents and students.

Since the dust has now settled down a bit, I’d like to add a little clarity relative to this particular scandal for all to consider.

A College Counselor’s Philosophy About Ethics

The student’s happiness has always been my main focus regardless of where they go to college.

I use the same philosophy with my daughter who is a sophomore.

Unfortunately, when I share this philosophy there are some clients who decide I’m not aggressive enough for their family.

And when that occurs, we part ways.

In all of my 15 years in this business I have never claimed to be giving a student an academic admission advantage.

That’s a promise I would never make to any of my students or families.

At the end of the day, the academic achievement and standardized test results, as well as their athletic and other attributes are the responsibility of the student.

Working with a college admissions advisor can have several significant advantages but it is the student who is ultimately responsible for their own admissions success.

I will never write an essay for a student.

I will never solely decide where a student should apply to college.

I will never do anything that I feel is unethical, immoral or not in the best interest of the student and family.

Any decent and trustworthy counselor you hire should behave in the same way.

I will not feel badly about the help, guidance, peace-of-mind and cost-effectiveness I help my students and families achieve as a result of working with me.

And, I don’t believe that they should feel guilty for identifying the fact that they could benefit from some professional help, support, and guidance.

Should I Hire a Professional College Counselor?

My answer is: It depends.

Have you ever gone on a trip?  

I’m sure when you were planning this trip you had the option of either doing it yourself or using a travel agent or consultant.

There are pros and cons in both scenarios.

Doing it by yourself can be less expensive, initially.

But if you do choose the DIY method you then have to become knowledgeable about your travel destination as well as how to optimize your time while you’re there.

The goal is to ensure that you and your family have a very good time on this trip, see and participate in all the activities you desire, and do it affordably.

Assuming you have the time and interest in doing this legwork, you can certainly do it yourself and have a great experience.

On the other hand, there are a lot of benefits to working with a professional in the travel field.

If they are properly educated and do the research necessary to excel at their job, they can offer choices to you based upon their expertise as well as suggest the most cost-effective way to travel.

In addition, they can make suggestions based upon their experience that will help ensure your safety, which is more significant when you travel to an unknown destination.

Who Should Hire a College Admissions Counselor?

For many families, the college admissions process is also a trip to an unknown destination. If you choose to navigate it yourself you can utilize free resources that are online, buy a book, or utilize the resources of your high school to achieve college admission success.

However, that doesn’t work for everybody for a host of reasons.

When you or someone you know is considering looking for outside college admissions help, it’s important to understand that it isn’t typically to gain a competitive admission advantage.

You hire outside admissions help so your student will have the best chance to achieve their desired potential, so they can avoid big admissions mistakes, and so you, the parents, are financially efficient as you all go through the process.

Do you have a financial advisor? A physical therapist? Like the travel agent, these professionals can help you manage your money, get back on the road to recovery faster, and in general, live a better life.

Would you ever attempt to do their jobs on your own?

There are reasons why people hire outside help.

The time that is required to become an “expert” may not fit into your schedule.

It may cost you a little more money up front, but if you choose the right person, peace-of-mind and trusted guidance will help you optimize your results while minimizing your stress and anxiety.

The college admissions process can be overwhelming, especially for dual-income families with multiple children.

Hiring an outside professional who is on the same page with the same goals and desires for you and your student can be incredibly valuable.

They can ensure you avoid the big mistakes as you go through the process and that you are cost-effective in the colleges you choose.

If they are the right match, they can help set up your student for future college success

Bumper Sticker Envy

 Don’t get caught up in “bumper sticker envy.”  

The key is to avoid trying to impress your neighbors, but instead making sure that the college you choose for your student is right for them (and your family) academically, socially, and financially.

In my years in this business I have found that many people have a skewed view that can lead them to make decisions for the wrong reasons.

Some students end up fine, I’m sure. But were they actually more successful or happier because they went to the “better” school?

All the dynamics that impact us as we go through life also apply to college and your student’s college experience.  

Name, reputation, and rankings cannot shield us from that fact.

But if that is the case, why do so many make decisions based upon idealistic factors rather than practical ones?

How Much Will a Professional College Counselor Cost?

Know that you don’t need to spend huge amounts of money for this help.

A subscription service, like Road2College Concierge Service is geared specifically towards families with high school students.

The Service was created to make access to experts affordable for most families and fill in the gap between having no help or spending thousands of dollars to get help.

Don’t Judge!

There will always be people on the athletic field, in the classroom, in the boardroom, and elsewhere. who will do anything to get a “leg up” on the competition, regardless of whether it is right.

That will never change despite this, and other scandals being publicized so broadly.

Conflating these people with all families and students who get help outside of what is provided in their school or online is wrong.

When people receive outside (legal) help, it most likely means that they are not sure how to navigate the process successfully.

They see the value in bringing in an expert because they want to make sure they do the best they can for their student and family.

I understand that many of us like to pass judgment when we find somebody who’s done something as incredibly unethical and wrong as these people involved in the scandal.

Families who have trusted the system and are now very disillusioned have every right to ask questions, and I encourage you to do so.

Let me put your mind at ease…so many people I know in this business have nothing but the well-being of the student and the financial interests of the families in mind.

When a family hires a reputable college counselor they should feel that that they allowed the success and happiness quotients for themselves and their student to ultimately drive their process. In my opinion no one should feel badly about that.

Wouldn’t you agree?







In this article:

Upcoming Events

Similar Articles for You

“The Best College Advice I’ve Received So Far”


“The Best College Advice I’ve Received So Far”

While there are tons of websites like this one that can help guide you on the road to college, there’s...

Help Your Young Adult Build Credit: Ensure Future Financial Success


Help Your Young Adult Build Credit: Ensure Future Financial Success

This article is sponsored by College Ave Student Loans, dedicated to helping students and families pay for higher education. Teaching...

The Difference Between SAT and ACT


The Difference Between SAT and ACT

One of the questions parents frequently ask is whether students should take the SAT or ACT. I always respond that...

Become a Member

At Road2College you’ll find everything you need to make the admissions and paying for college process less stressful and more transparent.


Explore R2C Insights™ — your source for finding affordable colleges and merit scholarships.


Get coaching on admissions and college financing.


Join Road2College where parents and experts work together to inform and inspire college-bound families.