Many families spend countless hours chasing private scholarships, but national studies show that nearly 90 percent of all grant aid comes directly from colleges and government programs.
That gap between effort and payoff is where many families go wrong. This guide outlines an institution-first strategy for merit scholarships, starting with where students apply rather than which external awards they pursue.
You’ll learn how to build a college list and application plan that positions you for large institutional awards, the kind that can reduce the college sticker price by tens of thousands of dollars. Private scholarships come later, as a final layer to help you reach your lowest possible net cost.
“Families often focus on private scholarships because they feel proactive, but most of the money is decided much earlier, based on where a student applies,” says Luanne Lee, a Certified College Planning Specialist. “College choice has far more impact on affordability than most families realize.”
Inside This Article:
- Step 1: Build a merit-optimized college list
- Step 2: Apply for institutional merit aid
- Step 3: Use private scholarships as a final layer
Article Overview:
Most merit scholarships are awarded directly by colleges, not through national competitions or private searches. Colleges use these awards as part of their enrollment strategy to attract students who strengthen their incoming class, which means the largest offers typically go to applicants who rank near the top of a school’s academic profile. This guide explains how institutional merit aid works, how to build a college list that maximizes eligibility, and how application timing affects awards. Private scholarships play a supporting role and are most effective after institutional aid is determined.
Step 1 – Build a Merit-Optimized College List
The single biggest factor in whether you receive meaningful merit aid is where you apply. Colleges use merit scholarships to attract applicants who strengthen their incoming class, which means your odds rise at schools where you stand out academically.
Merit aid is awarded based on a student’s academic profile relative to a college’s admitted students, while need-based aid is determined by family financial information. Because colleges use merit aid strategically to shape their incoming class, where a student applies often has a greater impact on affordability than how many scholarships they pursue.
In this step, you’ll build a college list that positions you get institutional merit, not just admission. Here is what to do:
- Start with your academic profile.
Gather the GPA colleges will see (typically unweighted, though some schools also publish weighted GPAs) and SAT or ACT scores if you plan to submit them. - Compare your stats to each college’s middle 50 percent data.
Most colleges publish the 25th to 75th percentile GPA and test score ranges for admitted students. These ranges show where the middle half of the class falls academically. - Apply the “top 25 percent rule.”
Colleges where your GPA or test scores are near or above the 75th percentile are the strongest candidates for merit aid. At these schools, you are more likely to be viewed as an applicant the college wants to attract with a tuition discount. - Identify likely merit schools.
Many families build a college list of safety, target, and reach schools based solely on admission odds. A merit-optimized list asks an additional question: Where is a student academically strong relative to the admitted student profile?“Merit aid isn’t about being a strong student in general. It’s about being a strong student for that school,” Lee explains. “The same student can look like a priority recruit at one college and completely average at another.”That distinction matters when evaluating merit potential. Schools where a student’s GPA or test scores place them near the top of the admitted range are more likely to offer predictable merit aid, while highly selective reach schools are less likely to offer significant merit, even for strong applicants. - Consider net cost, not just merit size.
Merit awards should be evaluated by their impact on net cost, not just the award amount. “It’s not the amount of the merit award that’s important, but what the award does to the bottom line cost,” Lee says. “Receiving a $40,000 annual merit award from a $95,000 COA school gives the bragging rights of ‘we got $160K in merit,’ but we shouldn’t dismiss the $15,000 awards from the $45,000 COA school.”
- Use a college data platform to simplify the process.
Instead of comparing dozens of college profiles manually, use a tool such as Road2College Insights to identify schools that are both a strong academic fit and historically generous with merit aid for applicants with similar profiles. Road2College Insights includes Compare College Offers, which lets users enter their actual offers and view crowdsourced offers from the same college. - Use merit aid data to refine your college list.
Some colleges rely heavily on institutional scholarships as part of their pricing strategy, while others use merit aid sparingly. Reviewing merit award patterns helps you focus on schools where tuition discounts are not just possible, but likely. Road2College’s guide to colleges with the best merit aid can help you identify which schools are historically generous and worth prioritizing.
Step 2 – Apply for Institutional Merit
Once you’ve built a merit-optimized college list, the next step is making sure you are actually considered for institutional merit aid. For most colleges, this process is simpler than families expect, but deadlines and details matter.
You need to submit the right materials, in the right order, at the right time. Here’s how:
- Submit college applications by merit or priority deadlines.
Many colleges award merit aid early in the admissions cycle. Missing a priority deadline can reduce or eliminate eligibility for institutional scholarships, even if you are later admitted. - Complete the FAFSA and include every college you plan to apply to.
Even when a scholarship is described as merit-based, colleges often require the FAFSA, Free Application for Federal Student Aid, to award or package institutional aid. Filing early helps ensure full consideration.“Everyone should submit the FAFSA, no matter what their financial situation,” Lee says. “Clients often ask me if they should file the FAFSA, and my answer is always yes. It’s how you’re going to get the majority of financial aid.” - Submit the CSS Profile where required.
Some private colleges use the CSS Profile in addition to the FAFSA. If a school requires it and you skip it, merit or need-based aid may be delayed or reduced. - Check each college’s scholarship page for separate requirements.
While most merit aid is awarded automatically, some colleges offer competitive scholarships that require additional essays, interviews, or applications. These requirements are usually listed on the financial aid or scholarship section of the college’s website. - Track deadlines carefully.
Merit deadlines often fall earlier than regular admissions deadlines. Create a simple tracking system so applications and forms are submitted on time for every school.
Step 3 – Use Private Scholarships as a Final Layer
Private scholarships can help reduce college costs, but they work best after institutional merit aid is secured. This step is about using outside scholarships strategically, without undermining the larger awards you’ve already earned.
This doesn’t mean private scholarships aren’t worth pursuing, but that time and effort should be proportional to their likely impact on your final cost.
What to do in this step:
- Review institutional aid offers first.
Before spending significant time on private scholarships, look closely at the merit and need-based aid each college has already offered. Institutional aid usually makes the biggest difference in net cost. - Focus on low-competition opportunities.
National scholarship searches often have low odds and small awards. Students and families typically see better results from local, employer-based, community foundation, and niche scholarships. - Ask how outside scholarships are applied.
Colleges handle private scholarships differently. Some reduce loans or work-study first, while others reduce institutional grants. Contact each financial aid office to understand how outside awards affect your package. - Avoid unintended scholarship displacement.
If a college reduces institutional grants when outside scholarships are added, winning more private money may not lower your final cost. Knowing the school’s policy helps you prioritize the right opportunities. - Use private scholarships to close remaining gaps.
The most effective use of private scholarships is to reduce what remains after institutional aid, such as remaining tuition, fees, or borrowing, not to replace large merit awards.
How Colleges Will Decide Your Merit Aid
Colleges do not award merit aid simply to reward achievement. They use merit scholarships as a pricing and enrollment tool to influence who enrolls and how much those students ultimately pay.
At most colleges, the published tuition price is not what the majority of students actually pay. Institutional grants and scholarships are used to adjust net price based on enrollment goals, competitiveness, and the academic profile of the students colleges want to attract.
Net prices differ substantially by institution type and selectivity. Less selective colleges and some public institutions often deliver lower net prices where substantial merit awards are common, while highly selective colleges frequently show higher net prices even when need-based aid is generous. Families that apply to colleges with different pricing approaches often see variation of tens of thousands of dollars in net price outcomes.
Road2College’s recent college pricing study shows that the gap between published tuition and what families actually pay can be substantial, particularly at colleges that rely heavily on institutional aid to shape affordability.
Public universities differ significantly in how they award merit aid. In-state students at public flagships and regional public colleges often see lower net costs, while out-of-state public universities can price similarly to private colleges. In many cases, institutional merit awards for nonresident students are less predictable and serve a different enrollment purpose.
National data explains why this pattern is so widespread. According to the College Board’s Trends in Student Aid 2022 report, 88 percent of all grant aid (including both merit and need-based) comes from colleges and government programs, while private and employer-funded scholarships account for 12 percent.
Colleges award merit aid based largely on an applicant’s academic position relative to that institution’s applicant pool. What matters most is how an applicant compares to other admitted students at a specific college. A student who appears exceptional in one applicant pool may appear average in another, which is why the same student can receive very different merit offers from different colleges.
Merit aid is also used to compete with peer institutions. When multiple colleges are trying to enroll the same student, particularly at institutions that do not consistently fill their classes from the most competitive segments of the applicant pool, scholarships become a tool to influence enrollment decisions.
Finally, merit aid helps colleges manage enrollment outcomes. Institutions use scholarships to shape class size, academic profile, geographic representation, intended majors, and yield. Merit budgets shift from year to year based on how the applicant pool develops and how enrollment targets are trending.
This system explains several outcomes that often surprise families and students:
- Strong applicants may receive little or no merit aid at highly selective colleges.
- The same applicants may receive substantial merit scholarships at less selective or mid-range institutions.
- Building the right college list often has a greater impact on affordability than applying for more private scholarships.
Private scholarships operate differently. They usually come from fixed funding pools, offer smaller award amounts, and attract large applicant pools. While they can help reduce costs, they rarely match the scale or predictability of institutional merit aid and may reduce institutional grants depending on a college’s scholarship displacement policies.
Understanding how colleges decide merit aid reinforces the core strategy of this guide: students and families have the most control over college affordability by choosing where to apply and by positioning themselves in applicant pools where their academic profile creates real leverage.
Merit Aid FAQ
What is a merit scholarship?
A merit scholarship is financial aid awarded based on academic achievement, talent, leadership, or other non-financial factors. Most merit scholarships come directly from colleges and are applied as institutional grants or tuition discounts.
How common are merit scholarships?
Merit aid is far more common than many families realize. At private nonprofit colleges, the majority of students receive some form of institutional grant aid, and a meaningful share of students at public colleges also receive merit-based awards.
What is the difference between merit aid and need-based aid?
Merit aid is awarded based on an applicant’s academic or personal profile, while need-based aid is awarded based on financial circumstances. Colleges often package both types together, but they are calculated using different criteria.
Do you have to demonstrate financial need to receive merit aid?
Not always. Many merit scholarships are awarded without regard to financial need. However, colleges may still require financial aid forms, such as the FAFSA or CSS Profile, to award or package merit aid.
What is the difference between a full-tuition and a full-ride scholarship?
A full-tuition scholarship covers tuition only. A full-ride scholarship typically covers tuition plus additional costs such as fees, housing, meals, and sometimes books or living expenses.
What is National Merit, and how does it affect college scholarships?
National Merit recognition is based on PSAT scores and can lead to scholarships from colleges or external organizations. Some colleges offer automatic or competitive awards to National Merit finalists, while others do not participate.
Can test-optional students still receive merit scholarships?
Yes. Many colleges award merit aid to test-optional applicants, using GPA, course rigor, and other academic factors. However, submitting strong test scores can increase merit potential at some schools.
Can you stack merit aid with need-based aid?
In many cases, yes. Colleges often combine merit and need-based aid in a single financial aid package. The total amount awarded depends on the college’s policies and the student’s eligibility.
Can private scholarships reduce institutional merit aid?
Sometimes. Some colleges reduce institutional grants when outside scholarships are applied, a practice known as scholarship displacement. Policies vary by school, which is why it’s important to ask how outside awards are treated.
Can you appeal or negotiate a merit scholarship?
Some colleges will review merit awards if a student receives a stronger offer from a comparable institution or if academic information changes. Appeals are not guaranteed, but they can be successful in certain situations.
_______
Use R2C Insights to help find merit aid and schools that fit the criteria most important to your student. You’ll not only save precious time, but your student will avoid the heartache of applying to schools they aren’t likely to get into or can’t afford to attend.
Looking for expert help on the road to college? See our 1-1 Coaching Services.
Other Articles You Might Like:
Dear Roadie: Should Our Daughter Pick Merit Aid Over Dream School Debt?
Top 30 Colleges with the Best Merit Scholarships
179 Good Small Colleges with High Acceptance Rates (and Generous Merit Aid)
JOIN ONE OF OUR FACEBOOK GROUPS & CONNECT WITH OTHER PARENTS:
