7 Tips for Making the Final College Choice

National College Decision Day

7 Tips for Making the Final College Choice

Published January 28, 2018 | Last Updated October 6th, 2023 at 11:10 am

National College Decision Day

The period of time between college acceptance and college decision is usually one of great soul searching.

By the time Decision Day (May 1st) rolls around, you will want your student to have (hopefully) picked a school that is the best fit on many levels.

As parents, it’s important to give guidance and support to help them make the wisest decision

Some may feel this is a step their child should take on their own, but we’re not sure how many parents could realistically leave a decision that has a potential financial impact of $200,000 or more to an 18 year-old. Instead, consider this a critical time to teach your child how to weigh the pros/cons of each school and work together to make the best college decision that fits academically, socially, and financially.

If your child is deliberating over which school to attend, consider the following tips to help them select a college that’s best for them.

How Do You Make a Final College Decision?

1. Compare Costs

Once a student has received their acceptance letter, or two or three from several different universities, your first step should be to analyze and compare costs.

Hopefully some of this work was done before applications were even submitted, but regardless, at this point there’s no time left to avoid understanding the net price of each school.

When reviewing financial aid offers, make sure to understand how much is “free” money, work study, federal student loans, and parent loans. Create a chart to compare the amounts.

In addition, look to our Compare College Offers tool. It will help you compare what your student was offered with what others with similar stats were offered at the same school.

Unfortunately, you may find schools determine “financial need” differently and some schools offer differing amounts of grants/loans to meet the level of need they choose. You can try appealing to the financial aid office to increase your offer or match an offer from another school.

From now till commitment deposits are due, you have the most leverage for negotiating a better financial aid package.

Colleges are concerned about their yield (how many students decide to attend after being accepted) and may be more flexible with their money. If you don’t ask, you’ll never know.

Remember to have a four-year focus and project forward for the next four years to estimate what the final loans may be upon graduation. Use loan repayment calculators to get an idea of how much the loan payments will be after graduation.

You should also research if any of the colleges have a tendency to “front-load” financial aid. This happens when colleges offer higher financial aid to freshmen to get them to enroll and less money to upperclassmen in the remaining years.

Factoring in financial aid offers and other financing options is essential to avoid excessive debt after graduation. Comparing these costs could weigh heavily on the final college decision made.

2. Visit the School in Person

Admitted student programs provide an excellent opportunity for your child to explore the campus at which they intend on spending the next four years.

From interacting with other students, to attending classes, these programs provide a real feel for the educational opportunities available through the university.

Even if there aren’t any of these types of programs, make plans to visit schools your student is considering, especially if you have never visited before. And in some cases, making a return visit can also help in the decision-making process.

While visiting, speak with current students and investigate where students spend most of their time studying or just socializing – this will give your student an inside look at the school. Making the best college decision involves all factors, so it’s important to investigate these aspects as well.

[More on what you need to know about accepted student day]

3. Choose a School with Plenty of Options for Majors

Students rarely stick with the major they choose in their first year of college, so it’s important to research how many other majors your student may be interested in and if they are offered at the schools he/she is considering.

This will ensure that if (and when) it comes time for them to change their major, they will they have plenty of additional options at the school.

Selecting a university that provides several potential majors is one way to help make sure your student graduates from school within four years.

4. Consider Your Student’s Personality to Make a Decision

Many people overlook their child’s personality when helping them make the final college choice. Does your student do better in smaller or larger classes?

What about their studying preferences?

Do they need more quiet time or do they function well in a more social environment?

Guide your student through these questions and help them see their importance when making this decision.’

5. Research if Credits Will Transfer to College

Some students may already have college-level credits from high school. It’s a good idea to ask the school which credits will transfer, and which ones they will likely have to retake.

Some schools accept AP or other college-level credits and apply these credits towards tuition. More often though, schools give the student credit to take classes beginning at a higher level.

Depending on the school’s policy, there may be the chance to use these credits to help graduate early (and save money), double major or just provide more academic flexibility when your student chooses classes.

Understanding a school’s policy on transfer and AP credits may play a factor in your student making their final college choice – gather all the information you can.

6. Ask for Advice

If your child is still having doubts about any of the schools he/she was accepted to, see it they can find current students to talk with.

Suggest they ask their high school for the names of past students who are currently attending any of these schools.

As a parent, ask friends and/or go online to local parent groups to ask other parents if they know of current students who have gone to any of the schools.

Often, getting a personal viewpoint is far more valuable than anything you can find on paper. Asking for honest guidance might reveal new points they hadn’t thought of before.

7. Don’t Forget About Extracurricular Activities

Sports, clubs, and fraternities are important to consider as well. While education and financial aspects are critical, extracurricular activities are important for developing team building and networking skills that can be used down the road.

Programs like these help students explore their interests and discover what they really love. Look for a college that represents your child’s sports preferences or talents so that the door is always open for them.

Your student should be at the center of make thisfinal college decision. After all, it is their future and happiness at stake. Using your parenting skills, however, you can help guide them in the right direction.

Making the best college decision involves considering personal, financial, social, and educational preferences, and factoring them all in when your student’s final college choice needs to be made.


Use R2C Insights to help find merit aid and schools that fit the criteria most important to your student. You’ll not only save precious time, but your student will avoid the heartache of applying to schools they aren’t likely to get into or can’t afford to attend.  

Other Articles You Might Like:

Extracurricular Activities: What They Are and How to Find Them

Top Questions to Ask Your Student Before Making the Ultimate College Decision

How Parents Can Help Students Handle Admissions Decisions




In this article:

Upcoming Events

Similar Articles for You

Comprehensive Guide to Co-Op Colleges: Where Education Meets Practical Experience

11th Graders

Comprehensive Guide to Co-Op Colleges: Where Education Meets Practical Experience

While work-study or your garden variety part-time job are some of the most traditional ways to make money in college,...

Ivy League Schools vs Public Ivy League: Which is the Better Choice?

College Admissions

Ivy League Schools vs Public Ivy League: Which is the Better Choice?

When it comes to prestigious colleges, the terms “Ivy League” and “Public Ivies” often come up. But what distinguishes these...

Your Guide to NESCAC Schools and Little Ivies


Your Guide to NESCAC Schools and Little Ivies

You’ll encounter many acronyms and terms as you forge ahead on the road to college. If you’re interested in Northeastern...

Become a Member

At Road2College you’ll find everything you need to make the admissions and paying for college process less stressful and more transparent.


Explore R2C Insights™ — your source for finding affordable colleges and merit scholarships.


Get coaching on admissions and college financing.


Join Road2College where parents and experts work together to inform and inspire college-bound families.